Step 5 · Questions & claims

What must this case establish?

Write the questions first. Then attach claims, each with the evidence it rests on. A claim's state has to match its citations, so nothing is called supported without a source.

Q-01 · asked by BJ

In what order were the recorded events between 21:00 and 22:00?

Supported
CL-01 The loading-bay door opened at 21:12:00
Recorded directly in the access log; no cited source conflicts.
E-04 ✓ row 18
Supported
CL-02 A trolley moved through the bay at 21:14:00
Recorded on E-02; time normalized for the 120 s clock offset inferred from two anchors.
E-02 ✓ timecode 00:39
Contradicted
CL-05 A separate door event happened at 21:09:00
Only the copied row in E-05 records it; the original access log and entrance camera conflict.
E-05 ✓ row 7 E-04 ✕ rows 17-18 E-01 ✕ timecode 00:14

Q-02 · asked by BJ

Did the 21:16 alarm come from the loading-bay door?

Inferred
CL-03 The 21:16 alarm came from the loading-bay door
The alarm audio does not name the door; the link relies on E-03 and E-04 together.
E-03 ✓ timecode 00:52 E-04 ✓ row 18

Q-03 · asked by BJ

Was EQ-4471 taken out on the trolley, and can the evidence say by whom?

Unresolved
CL-04 The person in E-01 is the holder of badge B-117
No source links the person on camera to a badge.
Unresolved
CL-06 EQ-4471 was on the trolley
The object on the trolley is obscured in E-02.

Add a question

Add a claim

Claim

Answers questionState

Why

Citations: the state must match them, or the claim is refused.

EvidenceRelationshipWhere

Every question has claims · Go to conclusion